SCO 1.3

The students will be expected to draw upon primary and/or secondary sources to demonstrate an understanding of the peace process ending WW1, including the following delineations.

Some definitions:

  1. Paris peace conference: the leaders of the victorious Allied powers met at Versailles in January 1919 to hammer out the peace treaties that would officially end WW1. People hoped that these treaties would mark the beginning of a lasting era of peace. Yet even before the treaties were ready to sign, those hopes were dashed.

  2. Fourteen points: goals outlined by American President Woodrow Wilson proposed as the basis for a just a lasting peace.

  3. Treaty of Versailles: Peace settlement negotiated at the Paris Peace Conference that ended WW1. It was the treaty signed between Germany and the Allies. Its terms included reparations payments, limitations on Germany’s military force, the surrender of Germany’s colonies, and the establishment of a League of Nations.

  4. “Big Three”: The men whose views had dominated the peace conference. These were Georges Clemenceau of France, David Lloyd George of Great Britain and Woodrow Wilson of the United States.

Georges Clemenceau David Lloyd George Woodrow Wilson
   Georges Clemenceau    David Lloyd George    Woodrow Wilson

SCO1.3.1

Summary of Wilson’s Fourteen Points (Wilson’s framework for peace)

See p.59 in text for Fourteen Points

Synthesis:

SCO 1.3.2

Analysis of France had to basic goals:

  1. National Security: France wanted to remove the threat from German military Power. Ultimately this resulted in France demanding the return of Alsace-Lorraine and the demilitarization of German Rhineland. The Allies would occupy the west bank of the Rhine River of 15 years and Germany would be prohibited from placing troops or fortifications within 50 km of the east bank.
  2. Reparations: monetary payments for damages due to the war.

  3. British Position: to ensure security of sea lanes to the British empire. This was to be achieved by crippling German sea Power and severely limiting Germany’s naval power.

Questions:

  1. Why did Great Britain not support France's demands for huge reparation payments and territorial demands? Text p.61

  2. Why did David Lloyd George and Winston Churchill not want Germany weakened too much? Text p. 61

SCO 1.#.3 Summarized the main terms of the Treaty of Versailles. (K)

see P.64 Text !!!!!!!!!!!

SCO 1.3.4

Evaluate whether or not the Treaty of Versailles was a just peace treaty. (i)

Student positions will undoubtedly vary Read pp. 62-63 in text.

SCO 1.3.5

Examine the purpose for creating the League of Nations.

The Purpose of the League of Nations was essentially to promote international cooperation. Its mandate was to maintain peace by settling disputes peacefully and by reducing world armaments.

Also, read pp. 76-79 in text!!!!!

SCO 1.3.6

Hypothesize the impact Versailles Treaty might have on creating German bitterness and threatening German stability during the postwar period. (i)

Treaty terms left anger and bitterness in Germany. The huge reparation payments would soon trigger runaway inflation and eventual economic collapse in Germany. Furthermore, military restrictions and the war guilt clause were humiliating. Thousands of disgruntled and demobilized German troops would later join wing political groups like Nazis.

Question:

Did the terms of the Versailles Treaty create such discontent Germany that the coming of another major war was inevitable?

The Great Depression:

Great 
Depression

Causes:

  1. Over-Production and Over-Expansion.

    Basic Economic Lesson: produce only as many items as you can sell.

  2. Canada’s dependence on a few primary resources.

  3. Canada’s Growing dependence on the United States.

  4. High tariffs choked off international trade.

  5. Too much credit buying.

  6. Too much credit buying of stocks.

Social/Economic effects of the Great Depression:

Russian Civil War

According to Marx, throughout history societies had been divided into two classes - the “haves” and the “have nots” - who always struggled with each other. In industrialized societies,the bourgeoisie (middle class) were the “haves” and the proletariat (working class), were the “have nots”. The “haves” controlled the means of producing goods and thus possessed great wealth and power. Although the proletlariast’s labour gives value to a product, workers get only wages while the owners of the factories gain wealth and power. The "have nots” perform the backbreaking labour but received low wages while enduring poor working conditions. Marx predicted that workers would join together to overthrow the bourgeoisie. “Workers of the world, unite” wrote Marx. “You have nothing to lose but your chains”.

Marx believed a classless society based upon the principles of communism would emerge in which everyone would share wealth and power. Marx described communism as a form of complete socialism in which the means of proudction (all land, mines, factories, railroads and businesses) would be owned by the people. (In reality, these would be owned and controlled by the state. Private property would in effect cease to exist).

Autocratic government of Nicholas II.

Many were upset because Nicholas II ruled Russia as an Autocrat) he alone ran the country and made decisions), and called for change in the politcial system. A state police called the Okhrana watched people who were against the Tsar. These people usually ended up in exile in bleak and isolated Siberia.

Nicholas II

   Nicholas II

Plight of peasants and factory workers.

Most Russians were peasants and, much of Russia’s farmland was of poor quality. Food shortages were common. In the winter of 1891-92, millions died of starvation. Russians peasants wanted to own their land instead or working for wealthy landlords.

Russians industrial workers were becomning more and more invloved in confrontations with the government over wages and working conditions.

Note: Landowning nobles were often rich and powerful. There were other rich Russians as well such as the capitalist. Capitalists used their money to set up banks and factories or to trade. They often made huge profits but paid low wages to workers and did very little to improve either working or living conditions of their workers.

Political reform demands by liberals and Marxists

Impact of Russo - Japanese War (1905) and World War I

Influence of Grigori Rasputin:

Rasputin was a self-proclaimed holy man who appeared to have a positive impact on Alexei’s haemophilia illness. He was especially important to the Tsarina Alexandra. When the Tsar went to the Front in 1915, Alexandra was left in charge in St. Petersburg. She turned to Rasputin for advice about everything. Ministers had to be approved by him and he gave orders about running the war. As Russia’s problems continued to go wrong, Rasputin was blamed for many of the country’s problems. Many of Russia’s nobles resented Rasputin to whom they were losing power and they found him to be rude and his behavior appalling (i.e. affairs with scores of women). In desperation, a group of nobles assassinated Rasputin but the damage was done. The Tsar, it was said was not fit to rule. He had allowed his German wife and a crazy monk to run the country while he went to fight the war. The Tsar had to go!

Grigori Rasputin

   Grigori Rasputin

SCO 2.1.4

Evaluation of how the policies of the Provisional Government led to its downfall and the Bolshevik takeover.

The provisional government adopted two policies that led to its downfall:

SCO 2.1.5

Comparison of the roles of political leaders in the Russian Revolution:

Alexander Kerensky (1811 - 1970): A Russian politician.

A democratic socialist, he became War Minister and weeks later Prime Minister in the Provisional government following the March Revolution of 1917. He was determined to keep Russia in World War 1, but his attempts to launch a powerful offensive in the summer were unpopular with the Russian people who were anxious for peace. He was pushed out of office by the Bolsheviks in the November Revolution of 1917.

Leon Trotsky (orig. Name Lev Davidovich Bronstein) (1879 - 1940):

He returned to Russia from exile in 1917 to join the Bolsheviks and played a leading role in their seizure of power. He became Commissar for Foreign Affairs (1917-18), and as Commissar for War (1918-25) he created the Red Army and was largely responsible for its success in the civil war(1918-20). After Lenin’s death, Stalin undermined Trotsky’s authority and gained control of the party administration. Trotsky was deprived from all his offices, expelled from the Communist Party in 1927 and exiled in 1929, but continued to agitate, intrigue and condemn Stalin’s ambitions. He was alleged to have organized, with the help of foreign governments, a vast plot to overthrow the Soviet regime, was sentenced to death in his absence (1937), and assassinated by a Soviet agent in Mexico City in 1940.

Vladimir Lenin (1870-1924)

With German help, he returned to Russia from exile in 1917. As a leader of the Bolsheviks, Lenin and his supporters steadily spread their views. Bolsheviks supporters made popular speeches in factories and at the front. They delivered Lenin’s ideas, simplified into the slogan "Peace, Land and Bread". This slogan appealed to many soldiers, workers and peasants. The Bolshevik newspaper Pravda(Truth) poured out anti-government propaganda and support grew for the Bolsheviks while it declined for the Provisional government.

Nicholas II (1868-1918)

Tsar of Russia from 1894-1917. During his reign the following events occurred : The Russo-Japanese War, alliance with Britain and France against the Central Powers in WWI, food shortages because of bad harvests, and the Russian revolutions of 1905 and 1917. Nicholas opposed badly needed political reform, although the 1905 revolution forced him to introduce the Duma, and from 1911 was unduly influenced in his choice of ministers by the unscrupulous Rasputin. He was forced to abdicate in 1917, and he and his family were executed by the Bolsheviks in 1918.

SCO 2.1.6

Events and immediate outcome of the Russian Civil War: (K)

Shortly after signing the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, civil war broke out in Russia (1920-1922). Lenin’s government the (The Reds) were opposed by the Whites. The Whites received foreign aid from Russia’s old allies who were angry with Lenin for pulling out of the war and his refusal to pay back all the money they had lent the Tsar. Western European countries were also afraid that communist ideas would spread to their countries and threaten capitalism and democracy. Leon Trotsky organized the Red Army and after the White Armies suffered defeats, foreign powers began to withdraw. The communists eventually prevailed.

SCO 2.1.7

Analysis of how Treaty of Brest-Litovsk and “war communism” enabled Lenin to consolidate power in Russia. (A)

Treaty of Brest-Litovsk: Lenin sent Trotsky to Brest-Litovsk to negotiate peace for Russia. The German-Austrian demands were harsh but Lenin was determined to end the war at any price. He knew that Russia was on the point of Civil war and it would be impossible for his government to fight the Germans and the Whites. Russia had to pay a huge fine for the German cost of war and had to hand over the following lands to Germany and Austria-Hungary:

Much of the territory lost included its most valuable farmland (i.e. Ukraine) and industrial areas around the Baltic.

Although many Russians were furious, Lenin believed that these sacrifices had to be made to save the revolutions.

Lenin introduced war communism during Civil War. This meant that the government took over the economy to make sure it had the weapons and food it needed. Government policies included:

SCO 2.1.8

Assessment of economic and social impact of the New Economic Policy(NEP) and Five Year Plans

New Economic Policy(NEP) In March 1921, Lenin announced the New Economic Policy, a program designed to rebuild the shattered Russian economy. The NEP eliminated many harsh measures of war communism and some return to capitalist practices. To encourage agricultural production, for example, the government stopped seizing grain from peasants. Peasants were encouraged to sell their surplus grain on the open market. The government kept control of heavy industry, railroads and banks but allowed small manufacturers to run their own business.

Result: The NEP lasted until 1928 and the Russian economy improved. Industry and agriculture improved. Industry and agriculture improved to prewar levels. Workers enjoyed shorter hours and better conditions. The government also relaxed terror and censorship.

New Economic Policy
Market under the New Economic Policy

Five Year Plans: Lenin had died in 1924 and after a power struggle within the communist party, Stalin emerged victorious over his main political rivalry, Leon Trotsky. By 1929 Stalin saw the Soviet Union (new name of the country since 1922) as being surrounded by enemies. He felt the nation militarily weak in the large part because its economy was not industrialized. He believed the only way Russia could survive a foreign attack was to develop its industry. In 1928, 1933 and 1938 he announced ambitious five-year plans outlining specific production goals in industry and agriculture. His five year plans poured Russian resources into building steel mills, electric power stations, cement plants and oil refineries, all industries essential to a strong modern nation.

Result: Impressive results were achieved in steel and oil production. By 1940 the Soviet Union had become the second largest producer of oil and steel in Europe. However, the quality of finished goods was often poor and economic goals were achieved at a tremendous sacrifice in human terms. Factories and workers were assigned production quotas and when not met the government often handed out punishment for laziness or sabotage (e.g. loss of jobs, homes, or food ration cards). Rewards were granted to those who reached production goals. Usually, however, targets were to hard to reach.

5 Year Plan Chart
Effects of the 5 Year Plans on Russia

SCO 2.1.9

Analysis of methods used by Stalin to exercise control over Soviet people.

To achieve his goals and exercise control over the Soviet people Stalin organized a totalitarian government whereby a single party dictatorship controlled every aspect of citizens’ lives. In totalitarian states individual rights count for little or nothing, absolute obedience to government is not to be questioned, critics are often silent and extreme nationalism is promoted.

Under Stalin, the government controlled newspapers, the radio, and all forms of communication. He censored the press and used it to pour out propaganda praising his policies. Soviet writers and artists were expected to glorify the Soviet Union and praise Stalin. Those who refused were often expelled from the Soviet Union, exiled to Siberia, or could not get their work published.

Stalin used terror to silence opposition to his rule and to increase his control. Two noteworthy examples include:

Collectivization: The NEP created a situation where some peasants grew rich by selling their surplus crops. They became known as Kulaks and hired poor peasants to work for them. Lenin’s policy allowed a capitalist class of peasants to develop. This was against communist beliefs. The farming system was inefficient and many were too poor to afford modern equipment (i.e. use of horse-drawn wooden ploughs instead of tractors). By 1927 Stalin felt Soviet agriculture had to be modernized. Besides, the Kulaks had always embarassed the government because communist ideas did not allow for individual profit-making. Stalin decided the Kulaks had to go.

In 1929 Collectivization was announced. All fields, machinery and animals were to be used to set up collective farms which would be farmed by whole villages and not by individual farmers. Many Kulaks protested by burning their crops and slaughtering their livestock rather than give them up to the state. Stalin responded by exiling an estimated 5 000 000 Kulaks to remote parts of the country (i.e. Serbia) or sent tem to labor camps where many died.

Note: By 1933, Soviet agriculture productivity had improved and the government did promote literacy on the farms.

Of course Stalin’s policies of collectivization and industrialization had made him many opponents. During the 1930s he decided to deal with anyone he thought was against him. He set up “purges” to eliminate “enemies of the state”. Between 1936 and 1953, over 40 000 000 people were arrested. About 24 000 000 of them were executed or died in labor camps. Many who were “purged” included loyal communists, military officers, and ordinary people like teachers and factory workers.

Fascism

SCO 2.2

Students will be expected to draw upon primary and/or secondary resources to demonstrate an understanding of the Great Depression and the emergence of and nature of Fascism in Italy and Germany.

2.2.1

Definitions:

  1. Wiemar Republic: The post-World War I German republic that governed Germany from 1913 to 1933. Germany’s selected parliament (Reichstag) was to be elected by proportional representation. This meant that if, for example, a party got 5% of the votes then it would get 5% of the seats in parliament. This encouraged the setting up of many political parties with the result that no single political party would likely win an outright majority of 51% of the seats. Therefore, governments had to be formed with groups of parties together to ensure they had the support of more than half of the elected representatives. The problem was that the parties in the coalition often quarreled. A president was to be elected who would have the power to appoint and dismiss the Chancellor or Prime Minister. He could also rule by decree in an emergency. This meant he could pass laws without parliament’s approval.

  2. Munich Beer Hall Putcsh: 1923 attempt by Adolf Hitler, leader of the Nazi party, and General Ludendorff to organize a march from Munich to Berlin to overthrow the Weimar Republic. The march was broken up by Bavarian police in Munich, and Hitler was arrested.

  3. New Deal: The economic and social program launched by F.D. Roosevelt to help the USA recover from the Depression. Examples:

  4. Enabling Act: Bill passed by the Reichstag which was to give Hitler power to make laws without parliament’s approval for four years. In other words it would make Hitler virtual dictator of Germany. Hitler soon outlawed all political parties except the National Socialist Workers’ Party (Nazis).

  5. Gestapo: The secret state police of Nazi Germany, headed by Himmler, and notorious for its ruthless interrogation methods.

    Gestapo illustration
    Cartoon used to show the Gestapo halting freedom of speech

  6. Anti-Semitism: the persecution of or discrimination against Jews.

  7. Nuremburg Laws: Laws passed in Nazi Germany (1935) discriminating against Jews.

  8. Kristallnacht: “The night of broken glass.” In 1938, after German diplomat was assassinated by Jewish youth a night of terror occurred across Germany against Jews. Synagogues, homes, and shops were set afire. Many Jews were arrested, beaten and even murdered.

    In the aftermath,the Jewish community was forced to pay for repairs. Jews could no longer own stores or businesses or engage in trade. Jewish children were banned from attending school. Places of public entertainment, culture, and sports were off limits. Driving licenses were revoked. All Jews were forced to wear yellow stars, symbolizing the Star of David, on their clothing as identification. Thousands were arrested and imprisoned. Still more were forced into ghettos, and then ultimately into Nazi death camps.

  9. March on Rome: A Fascist-inspired legend about the way in which Mussolini came to power in Italy. Throughout 1922 there was a danger of civil war in Italy, with the Fascist seizing control of several cities. Mussolini demanded a Fascist government and concentrated his supporters on the approaches to the capital. King Victor Emmanuel III gave way before the Fascist threat, dismissed the Prime Minister, and invited Mussolini to return from Milan to Rome to form a government.

  10. Mein Kampf: After the failure of the Munich Beer Hall Putch Hitler was convicted of treason and served a lenient sentence of 9 months in Landsberg prison. During this time he wrote his autobiography called Mein Kampf (My Struggle) in which explained his beliefs.

SCO 2.2.2.

Analysis of the basic elements of Fascim.

(Note: the term Fascism originated in Italy. Adolf Hitler also to this ideology.)

SCO 2.2.3

Assessment of how each played an important role in Mussolini’s rise to power in Italy.

Mussolini
Benito Mussolini

  1. Economic difficulties

    The depressed economic conditions in the aftermath of WWI led to pessimism about the future. Italy was impoverished and in chaos. In the south there was extreme poverty as many landless peasants scratched a living from the soil. In the north where most industry was located inflation (an increase and a decrease in value of currency) caused sharp price increases (560% between 1914 and 1921) and unemployment was rising. The socialists organized strikes (2,000 in 1920) and factory occupations (280 in Milan in 1919 alone). The socialists seemed about to launch a Bolshevik style Communist take-over. Big firms like Fiat and Pirelli looked desperately for someone to crush this threat. In the south the peasants began seizing land and the landowners were convinced that revolution was about to swamp the country.

  2. Weakness of Coalition Governments

    Between 1919 and 1922 Italy had five different coalition governments, none of which was able to make firm decisions. (See weakness of coalition governments in SCO 2.2.1 under Weimar Republic). Mussolini saw his chance.

  3. Industrialist fears of Socialism and Communism

    Mussolini promised the bosses and the landowners to smash the socialist-organized land and factory seizures. He would provide disciplined law and order. In 1919 he set up his own fascist party consisting of many former soldiers and let them loose to violently break the workers and peasants movements. Soon wealthy industrialists and landowners showed their gratitude with huge sums of money. Mussolini created a great impression as the King and the Pope hailed him as a man who would save Italy from the twin evils of communism and godlessness. In 1921 the liberal prime minister asked Mussolini to join the government’s election group. The fascists were becoming more popular and in 1921 Mussolini won 35 seats as opposed to none in 1919. The decisive event came in 1922 when the Socialists and the newly-formed Communist party called a general strike. Mussolini saw this as his chance. He demanded to be made Prime Minister and assembled 50 000 Blackshirts (his terror gang of thugs) in Florence, ready to march on the Rome and seize power by force if necessary. Being intimidated the King refused to act upon the Prime Minister's request to use Rome’s 12 000 regular troops against the Blackshirts, and asked Mussolini to become Italy’s new Prime Minister. He had taken power quite legally, having only threatened to use force. Before the end of 1925 free press and political parties would disappear

SCO 2.2.4

Examination of how the following posed a problem for the Weimar Republic and contributed to Adolf Hitler’s rise to power.

Hitler
Adolf Hitler
  1. Treaty of Versailles

    To many Germans, t he signing of the Treaty of Versailles with its harsh and humiliating terms was an unforgivable - a shameful blot on Germany’s proud tradition. The civilian government, not the army had been left the unpleasant task of suing for peace in 1918 and it was the Weimar Republic that would always be associated with defeat and humiliation. Hitler referred to them as The “November Criminals”. Later, Hitler’s Nazi Party vowed to avenge that dishonor and create a Germany that once again would be proud of itself and worthy of international respect.

  2. Economic Difficulties

    From the beginning the Weimar Republic was faced with economic instability which threatened its existence. The economy was in ruins and huge war debts and reparations payments overwhelmed the new treasury. The government printed money as needed leading to hyper inflation. This led to skyrocketing prices. German marks were worthless and many people were financially ruined. The savings of middle and working class people were wiped out resulting in bitterness and distrust toward the Weimar Republic and its politicians. Only the very wealthy escaped the terrible effects of the inflation because the value of their land and factories kept pace with the increase in prices. Due to proportional representation coalition governments often rose and fell. New, more radical parties such as the communists and the fascists often fought in the streets. In the midst of this political instability Hitler unsuccessfully attempted to overthrow the Weimar Republic in his Munic Hall Putch.

    The Crisis facing the Weimar Republic reached its peak in November 1923 but during the next 6 years, Germany experienced a period of economic prosperity. This economic success was brought about largely by American investment and loans provided by the Dawes Plan of 1924. However, when the New York stock exchange crashed in 1929, the Americans has no option but to pull out their investments from Germany and demand immediate repayment of loans. Within months, the German economy was reeling as business failed and unemployment levels soared. Political tensions rose and elections produced street battles and minority governments. Depression, social collapse, international humiliation and political chaos worked to destroy the Weimar Republic. The final blow came from Adolf Hitler. Soon the Nazi Party won stunning electoral success and, although having less than the majority, by 1932 was the largest party in the Reichstag. In January 1933, President Hindenburg appointed Hitler Chancellor as head of a coalition government. With elections called for March 1933 the Reichstag building was set on fire in February of 1933. Hitler accused the communists and persuaded Hindenburg to declare a state of emergency according to the constitution. After forming a coalition with the Nationalists whose 8% gave him 52% of the vote, Hitler would give the power to make laws without parliament's approval for four years. In other words, it made him a virtual dictator. The bill acquired its two-thirds majority with only the socialists voting against (The Communists had already been outlawed.). Before long Hitler the Enabling Act to outlaw all other political parties and Germany became a one party state - and all through the use of the constitution. When Hindenburg died in 1934 Hitler combined the offices of Chancellor and President. From this time onwards, he was known as the Fuhrer (leader).